Zero stars for all Indian cars in latest Global NCAP crash tests

by Autocar Pro News Desk , 17 May 2016


Despite the increasing awareness about vehicle safety in India, it seems manufacturers still have a long way to go when it comes to providing basic safety features on cars sold in the country. This is amply clear from the latest round of test results of Indian cars released by Global NCAP in Faridabad today, in which all the cars tested received zero star ratings.

In January 2014, Global NCAP published crash test results for five of India's best-known cars: the Maruti Suzuki Alto 800, the Hyundai i10, the Ford Figo, the Volkswagen Polo and the Tata Nano. All the cars received zero-star adult protection ratings. Volkswagen immediately decided to offer the Polo for sale in India with two airbags as standard. This model received a four-star safety rating. In November 2014, Global NCAP published crash test results for Nissan's Datsun Go and the Maruti Suzuki Swift. Both cars received zero-star adult protection ratings. 

In the latest round of tests, the global automotive safety watchdog tested five high selling Indian cars including the Renault Kwid, Maruti Suzuki Celerio, Maruti Suzuki Eeco, Mahindra Scorpio and Hyundai Eon, and found low levels of adult occupant protection on all these vehicles, which resulted in zero star ratings for all the five cars. The Renault Kwid was tested in three versions, including one with airbags, but each was rated as zero-star for adult safety.

All the cars were tested for crash safety at a speed of 64 kph at which the ‘unstable’ body shell on these cars collapsed, exposing the dummy occupants to life-threatening injuries.  

Unveiling the latest crash test results during the Indian Automobile Safety Conference hosted by IRTE in Faridabad, David Ward, Secretary General of Global NCAP said: “The latest ‘SaferCarsforIndia’ results show how important it is for cars to have a body shell that can remain stable in a crash. This is an absolutely crucial pre-requisite for occupant safety together with fitment at least of front airbags. It is very surprising that a manufacturer like Renault introduced the Kwid initially lacking this essential feature. Global NCAP strongly believes that no manufacturer anywhere in the world should be developing new models that are so clearly sub-standard.”

“Car makers must ensure that their new models pass the UN’s minimum crash test regulations, and support use of an airbag,” he added.

 “The results highlight the importance of the Indian Government’s decision to mandate front and side impact crash tests from October 2017. Legislative action is needed to ensure that the minimum levels of occupant protection recommended by the United Nations are guaranteed for Indian consumers. But manufacturers don’t have to wait for legislation and we urge them to act to eliminate all zero star cars from production as soon as possible.”

“Global NCAP also welcomes the forthcoming launch of a Bharat New Car Assessment Programme which can help build a market for safer cars in India,” Ward concluded.

How each car fared

Renault Kwid

Global NCAP tested the standard version of the Kwid without airbags. It scored zero stars in adult occupant protection and two-stars for child occupant protection. The collapse of the structure in the passenger compartment and the lack of airbags explained the poor result.

As a result of Global NCAP’s SaferCarsforIndia crash testing Renault has sought to improve the safety performance of the Kwid. Four versions of the Kwid have been produced with different safety features, with the fourth only recently released and yet to be tested by Global NCAP.

report-kwid-1

Following safety improvements, Renault proposed that Global NCAP test an updated evolution of the Kwid in production from early April 2016. The car was tested with and without an airbag.

The new Kwid without an airbag scored zero stars in the adult occupant protection and two-stars in child occupant protection. The structure did not collapse however it was rated as unstable and that it could not withstand further loadings. It was possible to see the structural reinforcements implemented in this version of the Kwid but when Global NCAP checked the left (passenger) side, there were no reinforcements. The structure was reinforced only on the driver side.

report-kwid-3-no-airbags

The new Kwid with the addition of driver airbag was also tested. This version also scored zero stars in the adult occupant protection and two-stars in child occupant protection. The structure was the same as the new KWID without airbags but a high compression in the dummy chest area explains the low score.

report-kwid-3-airbags

Renault has confirmed that they will implement further improvements to the KWID and Global NCAP will test these new evolutions in forthcoming crash tests.

“We welcome Renault’s efforts to correct this and we look forward to testing another improved version with airbags. Renault has a strong record of achievement in safety in Europe and it should offer the same commitment to its customers in India,” Ward added.

However, despite the safety improvements Renault has sought to introduce all of the versions tested to date have been rated as zero stars for adult protection.

Mahindra Scorpio

Mahindra Scorpio was the only SUV to be tested and the base variant which comes without airbags was the test mule. Despite the rugged image of the vehicle it shockingly scored zero stars in the adult occupant protection and only two stars in child occupant protection. The collapse of the structure combined with the lack of airbags explains the score for the adult occupant protection which means that there is a high probability of life threatening injuries for at least one of the adult passengers, Global NCAP said.

report-mahindra-scorpio

Maruti Suzuki Eeco

The Eeco without airbags scored zero stars in the adult occupant protection and one star in child occupant protection. The collapse of the structure in the passenger compartment and the lack of airbags explained the poor result in adult occupant protection. This model does not offer optional airbags. Nevertheless, considering the structural collapse airbags are not likely to help avoid life-threatening injuries to the driver, Global NCAP said.

report-eeco

Hyundai Eon

The Hyundai Eon is offered in the standard version without airbags. It scored zero stars in the adult occupant protection and two stars for child occupant protection. The unstable structure in the passenger compartment and the lack of airbags explained the poor result in adult occupant protection.

report-hyunai-eon

Maruti Suzuki Celerio

The non-airbag Maruti Suzuki Celerio scored zero stars in adult occupant protection and one star in child occupant protection. The lack of airbags explained the poor result in adult occupant protection.

The low score in child occupant protection is explained by the high values recorded in the 3-year-old child dummy as well as its forward excursion beyond the accepted limits.

report-celerio

Global NCAP will soon be conducting another round of tests for Indian car which will include two more OEMs and another version of the Renault Kwid.

Also read:

India’s new car assessment programme set to kick in soon

India’s top-selling cars continue to suffer on the safety front

Autocar Professional’s May 15 issue bats for increased safety, bowls a ‘Lighting Special’