After TVS Notice, Auto's Family Disputes Point to Settlement, Not Verdicts

Bajaj, Munjal and Kirloskar families split through settlements or arbitration, while there are no known cases of an Indian court ruling on a partition claim against a listed auto promoter family.

17 Nov 2026 | 9 Views | By Shahkar Abidi

The succession question hanging over the TVS group has turned into a formal legal claim. Dr. Lakshmi Venu has served a partition notice on her father, Venu Srinivasan, TVS Group Chairman Emeritus, seeking her share of the joint family assets of his branch of the TVS family and invoking the Hindu Succession Act.

In a statement on Monday, she said that as a daughter she is a coparcener; a family member with a birthright share in joint family property under Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, as amended in 2005,and that she has an independent right to seek partition. She said she was being "wrongfully denied" her rightful share. "Patriarchy has no place in law or in a progressive India," the statement said.

The notice covers the family's interests held through the VS Trust and other holding vehicles, spanning TVS Holdings, TVS Motor Company, TVS Credit Services and Sundaram-Clayton, the businesses allotted to the Venu Srinivasan branch under a 2020 arrangement that split the wider TVS family. TVS Holdings, a listed holding company, owns 50.26 percent of TVS Motor. The Chennai-headquartered TVS Motor reported Rs 47,270 crore of standalone revenue during FY26.

Her case rests on a distinction: that arrangement divided the larger family, she says, but no partition ever took place within her father's branch.

The claim has her mother's backing. Mallika Srinivasan, who heads farm equipment maker TAFE, endorsed her daughter's "legitimate right in the family assets.

Her counsel, senior advocate Aryama Sundaram, went further in a television interview. The assets "are certainly not his personal assets," he told CNBC-TV18, alleging that more than 90 percent of the joint assets appeared to be intended for her brother, Sudarshan Venu, chairman and managing director of TVS Motor Company. "I don't think anybody would say that a 90:10 or 95:5 split is equal or equitable," he said. A family memorandum of understanding signed in 2024, he argued, dealt only with brands, trademarks, non-compete terms and management roles. But did not provide for the division or transfer of ownership of family properties. If the notice goes unanswered, he said, a partition suit will follow and it will be for the courts to decide.

The Other Side

Venu Srinivasan, chairman emeritus of TVS Motor and chairman of TVS Holdings, has set out the opposite position. In a statement in October, he said the separation between his children was settled under a memorandum of understanding signed on March 20, 2024, capping a process that began in 2014 and conducted "openly, transparently" after consultation with the family. Sudarshan was designated to lead TVS Motor and TVS Holdings, while Lakshmi was entrusted with growing Sundaram-Clayton. "The separation was always about ownership and control," he said, adding that both children "were given a fair share on which they were and are free to build." He maintained the businesses and assets were his to deal with as he deemed fit. Neither he nor Sudarshan Venu has publicly responded to the notice. Several media reports suggest that a batch of about eight caveats were filed on October 12 and 13, 2026, before the Chennai City Civil Court, the Commercial Court in Chennai, and the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), with family members filing caveats against the other group. In legal parlance, a caveat is a routine step asking to be heard before any court passes an order.

None of the group's listed companies had disclosed anything to the stock exchanges about the dispute as of November 17. That is expected at this stage: the notice is addressed to Venu Srinivasan personally, and no suit has been filed.

What the Law Says

The statutory ground is settled. Since a 2005 amendment to the Hindu Succession Act, daughters are coparceners by birth in joint family property, with the same rights as sons. In Vineeta Sharma v Rakesh Sharma in 2020, the Supreme Court ruled that the right holds even if the father died before the amendment took effect.

The harder question is what kind of property this is. A person can deal with self-acquired property as he pleases; joint family or ancestral property is different. In Kalyani v Narayanan in 1980, the Supreme Court held that a father could not give away by will ancestral property in which his sons had acquired an interest by birth, and that a clear, communicated intention to separate is itself enough to sever a joint family, even before any property is divided. That reading sits awkwardly with a simple "my assets, my choice" defence if the assets are found to be ancestral.

However, there are nuances to it. While Kalyani v. Narayanan established that a communicated intention to separate severs joint family status, the Supreme Court in Vineeta Sharma tightened the evidentiary standard for claiming a prior partition to defeat a daughter's claim. Under Section 6(5) of the amended Act, a plea of oral partition or informal severance is generally not accepted unless backed by a registered partition deed, a court decree, or unimpeachable, contemporaneous public documents.

While the headline takeaway is straightforward, a bench of Justices Augustine George Masih and Sunita Agarwal grounded the ruling in four specific legal nuances. Under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, when a Hindu male dies without a will, his property devolves upon his Class I heirs (which includes his son, daughter, widow, and mother, not the son of a living son). Relying on precedents like C.W.T. v. Chander Sen, the Court reiterated that a son inheriting under Section 8 takes the property in his individual capacity, not as the Karta of a joint family. In this case, the grandfather (N. Ramakrishnan) died intestate, and his Class I heirs divided his estate through a 1994 compromise partition decree. Under Section 19 of the Act, co-heirs inheriting under Section 8 take as tenants-in-common (holding distinct, independent shares) rather than joint tenants. Once partitioned, the share allotted to the father became his absolute property, which he was legally free to sell without his child's consent. The Court noted a critical timeline detail: the grandfather had passed away and succession had already opened before the grandson (J. Rajesh) was born in January 1994. Because no undivided coparcenary remained intact when the grandson was born, none of the updated legal clauses could create a retroactive birthright for him.

This exact distinction explains why the factual history of the TVS assets is central to the dispute between Venu Srinivasan and Lakshmi Venu. If TVS shares and family businesses were held as joint family coparcenary property (or pooled into a family trust for joint family benefit without a prior statutory severance), Lakshmi Venu has a strong basis to claim an equal birthright as a coparcener under Section 6. Conversely, if Venu Srinivasan acquired his stakes through statutory succession under Section 8, through earlier corporate/family partitions (such as the 2020 wider TVS group restructuring), or built them independently, J. Rajesh v. M. Kumaran reinforces his position that those shares became his absolute individual property to distribute as he saw fit.

Precedents in the Auto Industry

The closest parallel sits in the same industry. The Kirloskar family's 2009 deed of family settlement divided the Pune engineering group among its branches, but fights over non-compete obligations and control of the trademark-holding company outlasted mediation and reached the courts. The Bombay High Court referred the dispute to arbitration, and in August this year the Supreme Court upheld that approach and appointed a three-member tribunal seated in Pune, leaving every question open for the arbitrators. Seventeen years after the deed, the split is still not fully resolved.

The Bajaj family found the exit earlier. A feud that began in 2002 sent Shishir Bajaj to the Company Law Board against his elder brother Rahul in 2003. The board pushed both sides to talk, and the settlement was sealed in December 2008 through share transfers, with no ruling on the merits. The group later separated its businesses into three listed companies.

The Munjals of the Hero Group skipped the courts entirely, realigning ownership among the family's sub-groups in 2010 and untangling cross-holdings while leaving management structures untouched.

The Likely Path

Two lessons stand out. Courts rarely decide these disputes on merits. They enforce the arbitration clauses written into family settlements, as in Kirloskar, or steer the parties toward compromise, as the Company Law Board did with the Bajajs. And the law on daughters' rights is no longer the contested ground. The fight, if it comes, will be over facts: whether the assets are joint family property, and what the 2020 arrangement and the 2024 memorandum actually changed.

What matters next is the response to the notice. While the family and auto industry in general still hopes for an amicable resolution. A partition suit in the Courts is the alternative, and Indian court history suggests that road is measured in years, not months.

RELATED ARTICLES

Porsche India Opens Country's Largest Aftersales Facility in Kolkata

Dev Vadchhedia 17 Nov 2026

The luxury carmaker launches a 32,000-square-foot service center featuring dedicated high-voltage battery repair capabil...

Exclusive: Mercedes-Benz Eyes 30% Cut in Vehicle Development Time as SDV Strategy Advances

Mukul Yudhveer Singh 17 Nov 2026

Steffen Tacke, Director R&D, Mercedes-Benz AG, says separating hardware, software and vehicle development cycles will he...

Amazon Commits $7 Billion For Renewable Energy Expansion In India

Dev Vadchhedia 17 Nov 2026

The e-commerce major announces fresh capital outlay alongside four new utility-scale wind and solar projects.

NEXT STORY