German automotive manufacturers have the engineering expertise and talent to regain global leadership, but need to give their people greater freedom, accelerate decision-making and develop new growth opportunities, according to Dr. Thomas Sedran, CEO of HÖRMANN Automotive and Founder of RyuWorks, who previously held senior leadership positions at Volkswagen Group and Opel.
Speaking at Vector Informatik’s Next Horizons 2026 conference in Stuttgart, Dr. Sedran presented his assessment of the German automotive industry’s future, drawing on lessons from Toyota, BYD, BMW, Tesla and Xiaomi. His presentation, titled ‘The Playbook for German Auto to Get Back to the Top’, was based on research for a book he co-authored examining how the industry could return to a position of global leadership.
Dr. Sedran described the industry’s current challenges as structural rather than cyclical. He cited changing geopolitical relationships, China’s emergence as a major automotive competitor, higher energy costs and European vehicle demand that remains around 20-30% below previous peak levels. The decline has left manufacturers with excess production capacity, while higher vehicle prices and reduced purchasing power have affected demand.
He nevertheless acknowledged the progress German manufacturers have made with their latest electric vehicles. Referring to recent Mercedes-Benz products, Dr. Sedran said manufacturers were developing increasingly capable vehicles after an initial generation of EVs that had not fully demonstrated their engineering potential. He also referred to his own involvement in the development of Volkswagen’s ID. Buzz.
Lessons from Five Automakers
Dr. Sedran identified Toyota as an example of operational excellence and consistency. He said the Japanese manufacturer had maintained relatively stable sales and revenues while Volkswagen Group was experiencing declining volumes. Toyota’s strength, in his assessment, lay in its ability to maintain high standards across its operations.
BYD offered a different example through its control over the electric vehicle value chain. Dr. Sedran highlighted the Chinese manufacturer’s approach to deciding which activities to undertake internally and which to outsource. He said this level of vertical integration had helped BYD establish a structural cost advantage.
Among premium manufacturers, Dr. Sedran singled out BMW for maintaining relatively stable volumes over the past five years, compared with declines at Audi and Mercedes-Benz. He acknowledged that BMW faced challenges of its own, but considered its execution of strategy more consistent over the period. In particular, he pointed to the company’s ability to maintain its direction without repeatedly reconsidering its strategic choices.
Tesla’s contribution, according to Dr. Sedran, extended beyond making electric vehicles attractive to customers. He said the company had demonstrated that electric mobility could be enjoyable and profitable, while establishing software as a fundamental part of vehicle development. Tesla’s practice of developing software internally and applying first-principles thinking to engineering decisions had helped it create advantages in product development.
Dr. Sedran also highlighted Xiaomi’s rapid entry into the premium automotive market. The Chinese technology company had developed and launched vehicles at a pace that challenged conventional automotive development practices. He regarded its speed of execution and early sales performance as particularly noteworthy.
Software, Speed and Decision-Making
Dr. Sedran also examined technology companies outside the automotive industry to understand how they respond to major changes in markets and technology. He said successful technology businesses placed considerable importance on speed, experimentation and the willingness to change direction when circumstances demanded it. Their incentive structures were often designed to support these priorities.
He cited Microsoft’s shift towards cloud computing under Satya Nadella as an example of decisive organisational change. Recalling a conversation with a former senior Microsoft sales executive in Europe, Dr. Sedran said the company’s sales incentives had been redirected from traditional Office products towards cloud services within a year. He contrasted this approach with the automotive industry’s tendency to make strategic changes more gradually.
For German automotive companies, Dr. Sedran identified software, data, batteries and artificial intelligence as important areas in which they needed to match the capabilities of leading companies. He argued that much of the required talent was already available within the industry. Drawing on his experience at Volkswagen, Audi, Porsche and other organisations, he said he had encountered capable people who could achieve more if given greater freedom to apply their expertise.
Dr. Sedran devoted considerable attention to the way automotive companies are managed. Referring to the concept of ‘humanocracy’, developed by authors Gary Hamel and Michele Zanini, he advocated smaller teams with greater decision-making authority and direct responsibility for financial performance. Such teams, he argued, could respond more effectively to customers and emerging business opportunities.
He questioned the industry’s longstanding emphasis on centralisation and the pursuit of organisational synergies. In his experience, companies had sometimes spent hundreds of millions pursuing efficiencies that ultimately failed to materialise. Giving individual teams clearer accountability, even at the expense of some centralised efficiencies, could produce better results.
Dr. Sedran also favoured allowing employees closest to customers to influence investment decisions and identify new business models. He questioned management structures in which seniority determined whose views received attention, regardless of technical expertise or market knowledge. Shared values and a clear corporate mission, he said, remained necessary to keep decentralised organisations working towards common objectives.
He argued that established processes should be questioned when they no longer served a useful purpose. Rules introduced many years earlier should not prevent employees from applying practical judgement or experimenting with better approaches. However, he acknowledged that decisions involving substantial costs or irreversible consequences required more careful consideration.
Growth Beyond Restructuring
Dr. Sedran said automotive companies first needed to address immediate financial and operational requirements, including reducing complexity, controlling costs and securing liquidity. He referred to his current work in the metal-forming supply industry as an example of these priorities. However, he maintained that a lasting turnaround would also require companies to identify and pursue growth.
For vehicle manufacturers, he highlighted the importance of strengthening brands and remaining consistent with their established values. He also saw opportunities for growth within existing markets, including Europe. These opportunities, in his assessment, needed to form part of a broader strategy rather than relying exclusively on cost reductions.
Autonomous mobility was another area he believed could create new business opportunities. Dr. Sedran said robotaxis would become a market, but questioned whether German manufacturers would participate in the underlying technology or primarily supply the vehicles on which autonomous systems operated. He expressed disappointment that an autonomous driving alliance he had hoped would help establish a European solution had been discontinued.
He also cautioned against viewing diversification into defence and drone manufacturing as a solution to the automotive industry’s excess capacity. Although such activities could offer opportunities, he questioned whether they could absorb the scale of unused capacity across the sector. Companies needed to examine the commercial potential of individual businesses rather than assume that diversification would resolve their existing challenges.
Concluding his presentation, Dr. Sedran said Germany’s automotive industry still had an opportunity to regain a leading position. He maintained that its future would depend on the decisions manufacturers and suppliers made about technology, organisational structures and growth. The engineering expertise was available, he argued, but companies needed to create the conditions for their people to put it to effective use.