Siloed thinking among automakers is making it difficult to establish common approaches to software-defined vehicles (SDVs), according to Prof. Dr.-Ing. Eric Sax, Head of the Institute for Information Processing Technology (ITIV) at Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT).
Speaking in an exclusive conversation with Autocar Professional on the sidelines of Vector NEXT HORIZONS 2026 in Stuttgart, Sax recalled earlier cooperation involving BMW, Daimler and Audi on automotive communication protocols. He contrasted those initiatives with the difficulties manufacturers face in working together today.
“Nowadays, it’s more silo thinking, and this is a hurdle,” Sax said.
He attributed the difficulties partly to commercial considerations and competition-related restrictions that limit cooperation between manufacturers. Sax said these factors have made it harder for automakers to pursue common technical approaches than in the past.
Sax also serves as Director of the Mobility Innovation Campus, a joint initiative of KIT and the University of Stuttgart. Before joining KIT in 2014, he headed electrical and electronic development at Daimler Buses worldwide. His earlier career included engineering leadership responsibilities at MBtech, where he was involved in hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) testing activities for Mercedes-Benz.
Asked what established automakers must change to develop software-defined vehicles, Sax pointed to traditional engineering practices and the need for a different approach to vehicle development. He said manufacturers such as Mercedes-Benz and BMW must find ways to combine their long experience in mechanical engineering with software-led development.
The shift also raises questions about which engineering responsibilities should remain with vehicle manufacturers and which can be assigned to suppliers.
“I think the integration part is still the OEM part,” Sax said.
He identified automated driving, energy optimisation and comfort functions as areas where automakers must bring together hardware and software components. While individual technologies can come from Tier-1 suppliers and other partners, he believes manufacturers should retain responsibility for overall system integration.
Sax was particularly cautious about outsourcing the integration of highly automated driving systems. He said he would not favour a Tier-1 supplier taking responsibility for integrating a complete Level 4 automated driving system.
He also referred to Volkswagen Group’s Cariad while discussing automakers’ efforts to build software development capabilities internally.
On the use of artificial intelligence and simulation in vehicle development, Sax expressed confidence in the progress being made in safety-critical testing. He cited high-performance computing, hardware-in-the-loop testing and model-based simulation as technologies that can support the validation of increasingly complex vehicle systems.
Sax believes testing expertise could become a competitive strength for premium automakers. He pointed to their established validation capabilities and emphasis on quality as areas where they could distinguish themselves from newer market entrants.
The conversation also covered India’s role in automotive software engineering. Sax recalled working with an engineering department in Bengaluru and spoke positively about the work undertaken by Indian engineers.
However, he cautioned that India’s strong focus on software engineering would need to change as AI takes on a greater share of development work. He said software engineering could be replaced by AI “to a certain extent”, requiring India to consider how its engineering capabilities should evolve.
Sax stopped short of recommending a specific approach, acknowledging that advising India on this transition was outside his expertise.
Asked whether AI-led simulation and virtual validation could accelerate the development of automated driving technologies for complex road environments such as India, Sax said such progress was essential. He pointed to engineering tools and systems engineering methods as ways to address these requirements.