Bombay HC Orders Bosch to Pay Rs 25L Each to Temporary Workers Over Unlawful Nashik Transfers

High Court upholds finding of malice in law but declines to order reinstatement at Nashik plant.

22 Nov 2026 | 5 Views | By Shruti Shiraguppi

The Bombay High Court has directed Bosch Limited to pay lump-sum compensation of Rs 25 lakh each to New Entrant Temporary Workmen (NETWs) covered by a labour dispute at its Nashik manufacturing facility, holding that the company had used transfers to distant locations as a means of discontinuing their services without following the lawful retrenchment process.

The High Court partly allowed Bosch's challenge to the Industrial Court's September 29, 2026 order. While upholding the finding that the transfers were unlawful on grounds of malice in law, it set aside the direction requiring Bosch to reinstate the workers at Nashik and substituted it with compensation of Rs 25 lakh per eligible worker.

In a judgment dated November 19, 2026, Justice Sandeep V. Marne held that the transfers of 521 temporary workers across the country were driven by an intention to remove surplus employees rather than genuine administrative requirements.

The court found that Bosch had devised the transfer mechanism to avoid paying wages to workers whose services were no longer required at its Nashik facility.

The dispute dates back to 2021, when Bosch introduced a system called 'Red-Light Activation', under which temporary workers were prevented from reporting to the factory on days when their services were not required.

The affected workers challenged the arrangement before the Industrial Court, which directed the company to pay them full wages even when work was not provided.

The Bombay High Court rejected Bosch's challenge to the interim relief on July 1, 2022. The Supreme Court subsequently dismissed the company's special leave petitions on July 22, 2024, declining to interfere with the wage-payment direction.

During the Supreme Court proceedings, Bosch had maintained that work was unavailable at Nashik and offered to provide alternative employment at other company locations.

It also proposed a settlement of Rs 14 lakh each for 457 workers who were willing to exit the company.

Following the dismissal of its challenge, Bosch called the workers back to duty on August 21, 2024, and paid arrears. However, on September 7, 2024, it issued transfer orders moving workers to different locations across India, citing a decline in demand for diesel injectors and reduced manufacturing requirements at Nashik.

The transfer orders covered 96 Mobility Aftermarkets (MA) divisions, which handle aftermarket sales requirements including spare parts, and four manufacturing locations. The workers were given five days to report to their new locations.

The court noted that several orders did not specify the exact workplace where employees were expected to report.

None of the transferred workers joined at the new locations. The union challenged the orders before the Industrial Court at Nashik, which initially refused to stay the transfers on September 30, 2024, but protected workers from coercive action for not reporting. The Bombay High Court directed an expedited decision in January 2025.

After the Supreme Court lifted the protection against coercive action in August 2025, Bosch initiated disciplinary proceedings against workers who had not joined their new locations. According to the union's submissions recorded in the High Court judgment, 235 of the 521 transferred workers were subsequently dismissed.

In February 2026, the Supreme Court clarified that the dismissal orders would be subject to the outcome of the workers' complaint challenging the transfers.

On September 29, 2026, the Industrial Court found Bosch guilty of unfair labour practices under Items 3, 9 and 10 of Schedule IV of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, 1971.

It set aside the transfer orders and directed the company to allow the affected workers to rejoin the Nashik plant within one month. Bosch subsequently challenged this decision before the Bombay High Court.

High Court upholds finding of unlawful transfers

The High Court rejected several grounds on which the Industrial Court had invalidated the transfers, but upheld its ultimate finding of unlawful conduct on the separate ground of malice in law.

The court set aside the finding that the transfers had been issued without proper management authority. It also rejected the conclusion that Bosch had violated Section 9A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which requires an employer to give 21 days' notice before changing specified conditions of service covered by the Act's Fourth Schedule.

The court reasoned that the workers' appointment letters expressly provided for transfers to establishments across India. In the absence of evidence establishing a change in their conditions of service, the transfers did not independently trigger the notice requirement under Section 9A.

It also rejected the finding of a violation of Central Standing Order 32, which concerns restrictions on transferring certain categories of workmen outside their establishment. The court considered the appointment conditions alongside Standing Order 33 and relevant Supreme Court precedents.

However, Justice Marne held that the transfers were not bona fide administrative decisions. The court found that Bosch had first attempted to discontinue work through Red-Light Activation and, after being directed to pay wages, resorted to transferring workers to distant locations where they were unlikely to report.

The judgment noted that more than 500 workers were transferred on a single day, given only five days to join and dispersed across locations without adequate particulars of their actual workplaces. It also found no material to establish that the aftermarket divisions had requested additional manpower.

The court observed that none of the transferred workers had been posted to an MA division in Maharashtra, despite the state's substantial vehicle population and aftermarket network.

It held that the company had used transfers as an indirect means of terminating employment rather than following the statutory retrenchment procedure. This constituted malice in law, a legal concept referring to the use of an otherwise available power for an improper or unlawful purpose, even without proof of personal animosity against individual workers.

The court therefore upheld the Industrial Court's conclusion that the transfers were unlawful, notwithstanding its disagreement with the Industrial Court's findings on the three technical grounds.

Production decline and workforce figures

Bosch argued that the Nashik plant had experienced a substantial reduction in demand following the exit of major automobile manufacturers from the diesel passenger vehicle segment. The company submitted production data indicating a 57% reduction in injector outward production and a 17% decline in nozzle production.

The union, meanwhile, relied on the company's workforce and financial figures to challenge the claim that the workers had become surplus.

According to its analysis presented before the court, permanent employment at the facility declined from 1,528 workers in FY2017 to 913 in FY2025, while production per workman increased from 5,850 units to 20,258 units over the same period.

The union also pointed to an increase in Bosch's turnover from Rs 3,700 crore in FY2018 to Rs 7,700 crore in FY2025. The figures and comparisons were presented by the union's counsel using company data and were not independently adopted as findings by the court.

Justice Marne did not consider it necessary to conclusively determine the extent of the production decline. He proceeded on the assumption that manufacturing activity had reduced following the discontinuation of diesel passenger car production by major customers, including Maruti Suzuki and Honda.

However, the court held that even a genuine reduction in manufacturing requirements did not justify the method adopted to discontinue the workers' services. Bosch was required to follow the statutory retrenchment procedure rather than use transfers to secure indirect terminations.

Compensation instead of reinstatement

While upholding the finding of unlawful transfers, the High Court declined to direct reinstatement at Nashik. It accepted that the workers had become surplus to the plant's manufacturing requirements and observed that reinstatement could lead to another prolonged round of litigation over their subsequent retrenchment.

The court instead decided to settle the dispute through monetary compensation.

During proceedings before the High Court, Bosch indicated its willingness to increase its earlier settlement offer of Rs 14 lakh per worker to Rs 18 lakh. The union's counsel, meanwhile, claimed that an unofficial offer of Rs 35 lakh per worker had been made.

Bosch's counsel expressed inability to pay the higher amount, and the settlement discussions failed.

In determining compensation, the court considered the workers' length of service, the unlawful nature of the transfers, wages payable from September 7, 2024, and the retrenchment compensation and other statutory dues that would otherwise become payable.

It also took into account the amounts already paid under interim orders relating to Red-Light Activation: Rs 3.5 lakh to 128 workers and approximately Rs 8.5 lakh to 470 workers.

The court accordingly directed Bosch to pay Rs 25 lakh to each NETW covered by Complaint (ULP) No. 46 of 2024 within six weeks. Any delay beyond the stipulated period will attract interest at 8% per annum.

The order does not specify the final number of compensation beneficiaries. Although 521 workers were transferred, the company is required to pay compensation to those covered by the specified complaint. The aggregate payout liability therefore cannot be established from the judgment alone.

Beyond the compensation, the workers will not be entitled to claim any further financial or service-related benefits from Bosch.

After the judgment was pronounced, the union sought a four-week stay on its operation. The High Court rejected the request, observing that Bosch had been directed to pay lump-sum compensation to the affected workers.

RELATED ARTICLES

VinFast Plans Three Electric Scooters for India, Local Production Next Year

Eshisha Java 21 Nov 2026

The Vietnamese automaker will introduce three locally manufactured electric scooters based on the Evo, Kyo and Kinet, wi...

MG Windsor EV Facelift Expected in 2027 With Longer Range

Eshisha Java 21 Nov 2026

MG Windsor facelift is expected in 2027 with a 61kWh battery pack, increased range, revised exterior design and interior...

Suzuki Access Gets Two New Colour Options; Prices Start At ₹83,086

Eshisha Java 21 Nov 2026

Suzuki Motorcycle India has introduced Metallic Royal Bronze and Metallic Mat Bordeaux Red for the Access 125, alongside...

NEXT STORY